Storage & Thawing

Freezing Gotta Eat Muffins How do Gotta Eat Muffins stay so deliciously moist?

It’s all in the freezing…

Gotta Eat Muffins are frozen directly after cooling, locking in all of the freshness. Muffins are delivered to the customer frozen (unless requested otherwise), and should be stored in the freezer until ready to eat.

Once thawed, every Gotta Eat Muffin tastes just as perfect as the day it was baked (and arguably, even better). The freshness is in the freezing. When it comes to baked goods, the freezer is your friend.

Thawing Instructions


Jumbo Muffins

30 seconds on high or 50 seconds at half power

Mini Muffins

1 muffin – 12 seconds
2 muffins – 20 seconds

Room Temperature

Jumbo Muffins

1 ½-2 hours

Mini Muffins

20-30 minutes